Error message

The file could not be created.

Parliament Votes on Election Candidate Gender Equity Bill

AGORA moderator's picture

Wednesday, October 19, 2016 marks the first anniversary of the Liberals being elected to power. I remember it as a day to celebrate! A day when the sun set on a dark decade in Canadian history and rose on a Canada filled with sunshine, promise and hope.

Unfortunately, today is also the day that the House of Commons will vote on NDP MP Kennedy Stewart's private member's bill C-237; the Candidate gender Equity Act.This act would make a minor amendment to the Canada Elections Act by altering financial incentives already in place in order to incentivize parties to ensure gender parity during elections.

Currently, political parties are eligible for a reimbursement of up to 50 percent of their election expenses when they meet certain conditions. Every political party has the option to refuse this public subsidy.

A simplified explanation of the proposed reimbursement changes under Bill C- 237 would work this way:

If party A puts forward 45 percent women candidates and 55 percent men candidates, the party loses none of its public subsidies. However, if party B puts forward 25% women candidates and 75% men candidates, then the public subsidy is reduced by 10 percent.

As the gender equity gap closes, access to taxpayer-funded reimbursement increases when all other pre-existing criteria are satisfied.

For the past 96 years, women have been able to run for elected office. During that time, women's participation peaked when they constituted 29 percent of candidates. Today, women fill a mere 26 percent of the seats in the House of Commons.

It's discouraging that even though women make up 52 percent of the population, they comprise just over one quarter of our federal representatives.

As of September 2016, Canada ranked 64th out of 191 countries when comparing gender equity in national parliaments. In fact, Canada dropped a full 43 places down the list since 1991. At this rate, it will be 2075 before Canada establishes gender equity in Parliament.

Implementing Bill C-237 would require Elections Canada to include gender on all nomination forms. This small change would allow trans-gender and non-binary individuals to self-identify, thereby providing parties with the ability to recruit candidates from broader segments of the population.

Stewart has suggested using the 45 percent male, 45 percent female, and 10 percent unspecified formula in his bill.

Bill C-237 will be voted on today. Prime Minister Trudeau has called on his government to vote against adopting Stewart's bill. Interestingly, nine MPs, including three Liberals and Green Party leader Elizabeth May, and 2 Senators have endorsed Bill C-237:

  • Pam Damoff, Liberal MP
  • Nathaniel Erskine-Smith, Liberal MP
  • Andy Fillmore, Liberal MP
  • Mobina Jaffer, Liberal Senator
  • Sheila Malcolmson, NDP MP
  • Niki Ashton, NDP MP
  • Irene Mathyssen, NDP MP
  • Sheri Benson, NDP MP
  • Nancy Ruth, Conservative Senator
  • Elizabeth May, MP and Green Party Leader
  • Marilène Gill, Bloc Québécois MP

Bill C-237 has also received support from Samara, Leadnow, YWCA Toronto, FairVote Canada, ACTRA, Groupes Femmes Politique et Démocratie, the Canadian Council of Muslim Women, and Jerry Dias from Unifor.

Stewart's bill "Provides constitutionally-allowable incentives to political parties if they run more women candidates with the overall goal of achieving gender parity in the House of Commons. Over 100 countries identified similar gendered biases in their electoral process and made adjustments. Bill C-237 implements measures similar to those used in France, Ireland and Portugal all of which use differing electoral systems."

Implementing Bill C-237 would have enhanced whichever form of proportional representation the Liberal government decides to implement. Instead, I wait with bated breath in anticipation of the Liberal government's plan to establish gender parity across all parties and within Parliament in time for the next election.

This Article has been cross-posted from: https://raisethehammer.org/article/3117/parliament_votes_on_election_candidate_gender_equity_bill